Can two parts of the same court system sharply differ in how they handle domestic violence cases?
MINNEAPOLIS (April 5, 2011) — The response to non-felony domestic violence cases in Hennepin County’s suburban courts differs substantially from that of the court in downtown Minneapolis, according to a new report being released tomorrow by WATCH.
Key findings in the report include the lack of accountability in the suburban courts for repeat
offenders of domestic violence; a lack of emphasis on victim safety; and the need to improve the environment in suburban courts. The
Improving the Response to Misdemeanor Domestic Violence Cases, highlighted
practices which make it easier for repeat offenders of domestic violence to go undetected. Among these practices are the lack of consequences for violating court orders and insufficient time allotted for thorough pre-sentence investigations (PSIs), according to Marna Anderson, executive director of WATCH.
While the downtown court in Minneapolis allocates one week for PSIs, the Hennepin County
suburban courts allocate only four hours. By contrast, Anderson noted, the Ramsey County Courts allocate four weeks for PSIs.
“Four hours is totally inadequate for combing through the records of offenders, especially repeat
offenders whose records often span multiple jurisdictions,” said Anderson.
“It becomes even more unrealistic in those municipalities which share a part-time prosecutor.
Important information is often missed or overlooked that would identify perpetrators as repeat offenders, allowing them to fly under the radar of the justice system because they avoid a criminal record.
“Yet we know that perpetrators of domestic violence tend to escalate their violent behavior until
stopped by the courts or, in some tragic cases, serious harm to the partner that sometimes ends in murder. The courts lose a valuable opportunity to track offenders, while the offenders, more likely than not, continue their violent behavior,” added Anderson.
Among some of the other findings in the report, • In 25 percent of the domestic violence cases monitored by WATCH in the suburban courts,
no pre-sentence investigation was ordered. This only happened seven percent of the time in the Minneapolis DV court.
• Twenty-five percent of domestic violence defendants convicted in the suburban courts were
sentenced to probation without supervision.
• In one-third of the domestic violence cases before the suburban courts, judges failed to
explain the no contact order to the defendants.
• Monitors who gathered information for this report documented that it was difficult or
impossible to hear the proceedings 54 percent of the time.
Altogether, 31 volunteers and six WATCH staff members spent nearly 2,000 hours monitoring
close to 1,500 appearances. The project was funded by a grant from the U.S. Department of Justice and Minnesota Department of Public Safety.
Among the report’s many recommendations were the following: • Develop a multi-disciplinary domestic violence steering committee in the suburban courts to
oversee how cases are handled and to monitor progress towards an improved response.
• Require that PSIs be conducted in all domestic violence cases regardless of the convicted
offense. Allow probation officers more time to complete PSIs.
• Reduce or eliminate probation to the court in domestic violence cases, and create a system for
victims to report violations when offenders are unsupervised.
For a complete set of findings and recommendations, and a copy of the report, visit watchmn.org.
For more information, contact:
Marna Anderson, WATCH, 612-341-2747, ext. 5
How long does a hair transplant procedure take? It depends on the number of hair grafts that are transplanted and usual y ranges from 5 to 8 hours. Am I awake during the procedure?Yes. A local anesthetic is used to numb the scalp, al owing you to read, listen to music, watch television or sleep. Is a hair transplant painful?One of the main goals of the TrueHair™ program is to provide excel e
The full list of UAE controlled drugs (April 2007), Courtesy of the US Embassy in the UAE. … A source from the Ministry of Health said al control ed drugs are available in the UAE, but they are only dispensed by government pharmacies with strict precautions. "Control ed drugs may originate from morphine-based formulas or opiates and are highly addictive and can cause psychological