Just-in-Time Delivery Comes to Knowledge Management by Thomas H. Davenport and John Glaser The Best ofIntentions John Humphreys Let’s Put Consumers in Charge ofHealth Care Regina E. Herzlinger Management by Fire: A Conversation with ChefAnthony Bourdain When Paranoia Makes Sense The Growth Crisis – and How to Escape It The Mismanagement ofCustomer Loyalty Campaigning for Change Just-in-Time Delivery Comes to Knowledge Management Thomas H. Davenport and John Glaser Make Your Values Mean Something Patrick M. Lencioni by Thomas H. Davenport and John Glaser
stantly changing. Clearly, it is difficult
generated in his field and still do his job.
This is not a trivial problem. It is, quite
literally, a matter of life and death. Over
a series of studies on medical errors. The
Medicine’s 1999 report To Err Is Human
each year are attributable to medical er-
rors. Partners’ own research in 1995 sug-
ical literature. Even if he were to consult
tient reactions were serious, life threat-
other hospitals and physicians’ groups),
Copyright 2002 by Harvard Business School Publishing Corporation. All rights reserved. B E S T P R A C T I C E • J u s t - i n - Ti m e K n o w l e d g e M a n a g e m e n t
tory tests ordered by physicians in Brig-
bitious and risky project to link massive
to success, we’ve found, is to bake spe-
ported doctors’work processes. The proj-
to address Dr. Goldszer’s problem. Part-
believe, occur because the clinicians must
in a given profession is not restricted to
similar to Dr. Goldszer’s, though gener-
ally theirs are less life threatening. No
quality of physicians’ decision making –
tient care. But it was also risky because
spotty record of success in their first in-
all the rage in the mid- to late 1990s, is
same philosophy. In this article, we’ll
Partners didn’t really know if it would
still a good idea, but it needs a new ap-
few Partners hospitals. We’ll also con-
narrowly at first. Partners professionals
possible–or impossible–to bake knowl-
pected to participate in these activities
in addition to doing their regular jobs. Partners’ Ambitious Project
expensive. It’s not an undertaking that
without a very good reason. A decade ago,
have been only marginally successful. Thomas H. Davenport is the director of Accenture’s Institute for Strategic Change
of treatment, they’re translating their
in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and a man-agement professor at Babson College in
actions at Partners hospitals. That these
Wellesley, Massachusetts. John Glaser is the vice president and CIO of Partners
ing in direct opposition to their healing
J u s t - i n - Ti m e K n o w l e d g e M a n a g e m e n t • B E S T P R A C T I C E
nurses’ station, and the nurse can decide
may note that a particular test is gener-
toms identified or that it has been per-
this system, but it’s not the only one.
Partners’ approach is built on a set of
nologies. Such practices are still in their
records systems–that physicians can use
phisticated screens for the physicians’
from a single database of clinical infor-
precipitously. By the time he is flown to
series of checks and decision rules.
Cape Cod Hospital, it might be too late.
Here’s how it works. Let’s say Dr.
If a specialist in Boston, or for that mat-
tory arrest, but, as long as the history
ter in Tel Aviv, can interview the patient
of sleep apnea is noted in the patient’s
the physician to that potential problem.
scan results, the likelihood of effective
It also takes into account the patient’s
lergic reactions to any medications.
ication, but she once had an allergic re-
brings that reaction to Goldszer’s atten-
view of patient medical records as well.
out. The organization’s on-line sources
For example, the system alerts the physi-
(collectively called The Handbook) in-
cian, as he or she reviews Mrs. Smith’s
a rash, or major, like going into shock.
Mrs. Johnson’s reaction was a rash. Gold-
szer decides to override the computer’s
her cholesterol levels. In addition, it may
their use, and even on-line textbooks.
weighs the negative effects of a relatively
through an integrated intranet portal.
physician isn’t treating a patient directly
It’s an unusually good set of resources,
tals can consult. The Handbook is ac-
cessed, across all Partners institutions,
is linked not just with the clinical data-
talized patient’s monitored health indi-
base but also with the patient’s records
B E S T P R A C T I C E • J u s t - i n - Ti m e K n o w l e d g e M a n a g e m e n t
though it’s invisible to the clinicians, the
practice figures changed. However, Part-
tice, has some early data suggesting that
Keys to Success
for more than a decade, it’s still not com-
Developing a system like Partners’ isn’t
mittees. Teams of specialists design care
easy – from either a technical or a man-
ble within the organization’s two flag-
has not yet been codified for all the dis-
eases that Partners physicians treat. But
the approach is clearly beneficial. A con-
trolled study of the system’s impact on
Prioritized Processes and Knowledge Domains. Since these initiatives are dif-
patient-record system, a clinical-decision
cial, but important decisions still needed
ties, but Partners’ real-time knowledge
specialist–and in what order. Fields with
are more difficult to include in the knowl-
Several of these aspects – each of which
edge systems. In general, it’s preferable
given fewer times per day, the percent of
to develop systems in fields with low lev-
Support from the Best and Brightest.
tients requiring bed rest also needed the
Building a system like Partners’ is a chal-
Final Decisions by the Experts. With
vironment or field they’re in, to support
lives, they also save money. For starters,
the system and the new way of working.
the system if it challenged their role –
hospital stays and repeat tests that result
can easily lead to mistakes, Partners’ sys-
An Expert and Up-to-Date Knowledge Base. If Partners’ clinical database in-
lete knowledge, it would put patients –
and Partners itself – at high risk. Thus,
that U.S. insurers have not yet seen their
J u s t - i n - Ti m e K n o w l e d g e M a n a g e m e n t • B E S T P R A C T I C E
are generated, a third to a half of the or-
ders are canceled. The hospital’s event-
3,000 alerts per year; as a result of these
never successfully build a system of this
health care, this discipline is called med-
A Culture of Measurement. In order
cruited leaders in this field. It has several
fessionals are different from other know-
to assess how well it’s working, an orga-
Clinical Information Systems R&D. The
they’ve historically enjoyed high levels
of autonomy; they’re sufficiently power-
cians are also researchers. Its knowledge
ence, statistics, and medical informatics.
In general, it’s easier to embed knowl-
ers; the higher you go, the harder it gets.
ple illustrates that it is indeed possible
as justifications and progress reporting
highly skilled reps at high-tech firms like
The Right Information and IT People.
applied to business problems, it’s tempt-
ing to attribute any success to the tech-
nology. But in the case of Partners’ sys-
signers – depend increasingly on knowl-
To place an order, call 1-800-988-0886.
S&L00123 Slug Menu Band C 9pm:Layout 1 15/9/08 12:31 Page 1Succulent sausage, bacon, roasted vine tomatoes and mushroom, with two free-range eggs, served withDry and full of vibrant fruit, with a hint of zest. Roasted vine tomatoes, mushroom, baked beans Brimming with rich, velvety berries. and oven-baked potato wedges, with two free-rangeCreamy soft peach and pineapple fruit flavou
W E E K L Y • W E E K L Y • W E E K L Y • W E E K L Y • W E E K L Y Future of GA Forestry Committee Welcomes SPAN to Meeting As mentioned in a previous Management Update Weekly newsletter, a joint Senate and House committee was formed by GA Governor Sonny Perdue to explore ways to revive the state’s forest products industry. The committee held it’s first meeting earlier this week