Human factors & aviation medicine september-october 1994
F L I G H T S A F E T Y F O U N D A T I O N
HUMAN FACTORS & AVIATION MEDICINE For Everyone Concerned with the Safety of FlightAir Crews Face Stomach and Intestinal Illness Risks at Many Layover Sites Around the World Medications are available to help prevent and treat intestinal illnesses caused by bacteria and viruses. Pilots should consult an aviation medical examiner before taking antibacterial and antiviral medications, but avoiding certain foods and drinks may be the best strategy for prevention of illness. Wright State University School of Medicine
During layovers, air crews risk food poisoning, particularly in
the condition, and to determine the crew member’s flight
developing countries. Advance planning to avoid contracting
fitness status. Notifying the other crew members, company
food- and water-borne bacteria or viruses, which can cause
flight operations personnel and any available medical
“travelers’ diarrhea” and other gastrointestinal upsets including
personnel is the first step. The notification can be in person,
vomiting, will minimize the chances of becoming a victim.
by telephone or by radio (if in flight). Those notified shouldbe apprised of the symptoms (what the victim feels, e.g.,
A crew member might experience nausea, fever, head-
weakness, nausea, fever or headache) and signs (what can
ache, rapid heart rate, gastrointestinal colic, vomiting, di-
be seen by others, e.g., vomiting or diarrhea).
arrhea and other symptoms and clinical signs of acutegastrointestinal illness. Severity can range from barely
Most cases of travelers’ stomach and intestinal upset are
ascribed to bacteria, viruses or both. In most cases, aspecific cause is not sought because, following treat-
When gastrointestinal illness attacks a crew member on duty
ment, the condition usually goes away with no need for
or on a layover, the problems are to decide what to do about
Bacteria and Viruses Are Common
physicians.3 Noroxin (norfloxacin) may also be given. An-
Causes of Gastrointestinal Illness
other substance, Vibramycin (doxycycline), is also pre-scribed at times. These medications are prescription drugs.
Common causes of gastrointestinal upset with diarrhea are the
Bismuth subsalicylate (available in nonprescription medica-
group of bacteria known as E. coli. In addition, Shigella and
tions such as Pepto Bismol) has often been found to be effec-
Salmonella bacteria are often culprits, and a group known as
tive for prevention and for symptom treatment, when symptoms
Campylobacter has also been found to cause these intestinal
begin.4 It is best to get some advance advice from a physician
upsets and diarrhea. Various gastrointestinal viruses have been
about such medication’s characteristics and treatment regime.
pronounced causes. A little one-celled protozoa, Giardia, mayoccasionally cause diarrhea that lingers for weeks. It is neces-
Also available without a prescription is loperamide hydro-
sary to obtain stool tests to clearly establish the presence of
chloride (available in nonprescription medications such as
this organism. Another agent, Cryptosporidium, has been found
Imodium), a medicine that slows intestinal motility (move-
as a cause of diarrhea in Russia and, from time to time, in the
ment). It is used almost exclusively for treatment following
drinking water in certain U.S. cities.
onset of diarrheal symptoms.4 It should not be used for morethan two days except under supervision by a physician.
A traveler to an area where there is a probability of exposureto one or more of these organisms can obtain preventive medi-cation from a physician to keep symptoms from occurring
Precautions Can Minimize
should some of these organisms be ingested.1 Areas with the
Layover Medical Risks
greatest risk are in developing countries.2
When flying to areas where travelers commonly experi-
The side effects of these preventive medicines may prohibit
ence gastrointestinal illnesses, other precautions can be
operation of an aircraft because of physical or mental impair-
taken that will minimize (but not completely eliminate)
ment. Each crew member must be considered individually for
the risk of swallowing bacteria or viruses. Avoid drinking
any treatment or preventive procedure. Pilots should always
tap water or any water that likely came directly from a
discuss with a flight surgeon medications that they intend to
faucet. Instead, use bottled water and beverages that inso-
far as can be determined contain uncontaminated, sterileor pasteurized contents.
The choice of medication depends on the suspected organismand the individual patient, and should be selected by a physi-
Faucet water, if used for brushing the teeth, can be a source
cian. Table 1 gives general guidelines.
of bacterial or virus ingestion. This danger is frequentlyoverlooked by otherwise cautious individuals. Using
Antibiotics known as Cipro (Ciprofloxacin) and Floxin
uncontaminated bottled water when brushing avoids this
(Ofloxacin) are sometimes prescribed as preventatives by
General Guidelines for Treatment of Stomach and Intestinal Illness Occurrence Probable Cause Treatment
(Re-formed toxin infood — food poisoning)
FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION • HUMAN FACTORS & AVIATION MEDICINE • SEPTEMBER–OCTOBER 1994
Raw fruits and vegetables can be contaminated in many loca-
meats, especially fowl and seafood, omelettes and some
tions because of the use of human waste as fertilizer in fields
high-risk desserts, including those with meringue.
where fruits and vegetables are grown. In addition, workerspicking these items may, through unhygienic conditions and
Every airline should have an action plan that enables treat-
practices, contaminate the produce. The same can occur in
ment for illnesses at layover sites. Preventive medications, with
kitchens where these items are prepared as salads, fruit cups
instructions approved by a company doctor or an aviation
or juices. In such areas, it is better to rely on boxed cereals as
medical examiner, should be carried. Procedures to obtain
therapeutic medications should be established at each layoversite and the action plan should be coordinated and supervised
Some hotels in developing countries have their own water pro-
cessing systems and kitchens that meet sanitary standardsequivalent to those in more developed countries. Thus, crew
References
layovers should be in hotels selected for high quality healthstandards.
DuPont, H. and Ericsson, C. “Prevention and Treatmentof Travelers’ Diarrhea.” New England Journal of Medi-
The irritative effects of alcohol on the esophagus, the esoph-
cine Volume 328 (June 24, 1993):25.
ageal stomach junction and the stomach lining are well estab-lished. Judicious travelers should avoid or limit alcoholic
Steffen, R.; Rickenbach, M.; Wilhelm, U.; Helminger, A.
beverage consumption when in areas where the risk of gas-
and Schar, M. “Health Problems After Travel to Develop-
ing Countries.” Journal of Infectious Disease Volume 156(1987):84–91.
One strategy that can be used for brief periods in high-riskareas is to carry food bars that can be substituted for res-
Taylor, D.; Sanchez, J.; Candler, W.; Thornton, S.;
taurant meals. Beware of street vendors in developing coun-
McQueen, C. and Echeverria, P. “Treatment of Travelers’
tries who offer finger-held foods ranging from sweets to
Diarrhea: Ciprofloxacin and Loperamide.” Annual of
grain and meat products. Numerous reports exist of gastro-
Internal Medicine Volume 114 (1991):731–734.
intestinal illnesses acquired from these foods. Unpasteur-ized cheese, ice cream made with unpasteurized milk,
Johnson, P.; Ericsson, C.; DuPont, H.; Morgan, D.; Bitsura,
meringues (which are made with uncooked egg whites) and
J. and Wood, L. “Comparison of Loperamide with Bis-
numerous other items carry a high risk. Also to be avoided
muth Subsalicylate for the Treatment of Acute Travelers’
is raw or barely cooked meat or fish. The risk of meat conta-
Diarrhea.” Journal of the American Medical Association
It is important to avoid food that has been left outside for
Mohler, S. “Controlling the Hazards of Aircrew Food
an hour or more following removal from a refrigerator or a
Poisoning.” Human Factors & Aviation Medicine Volume
chilled area, giving gastrointestinal disease–causing bacte-
About the Author Inflight Meals May Also Pose Risks Stanley R. Mohler, M.D., is a professor and vice chairman atWright State University School of Medicine in Dayton, Ohio,
Even inflight meals represent a possible risk for crew mem-
U.S. He is director of aerospace medicine at the university.
bers. Through the years, numerous cases of multiple food poi-soning have resulted from on-board airline food.5
Mohler, an airline transport pilot and certified flight instructor,was director of the U.S. Federal Aviation Agency’s Civil Avia-
During the past two decades, catering services have made
tion Medicine Research Institute (now the Civil Aeromedical
progress in ensuring that the foods they deliver to aircraft
Institute) for five years and chief of the Aeromedical Applica-
are free of hazardous viral or bacterial contaminants.
Nevertheless, departure delays can result in food warmingfrom its refrigerated state while sitting on the tarmac before
He has written several books on pilot medications and a book
loading. Under these circumstances it is prudent to avoid
FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION • HUMAN FACTORS & AVIATION MEDICINE • SEPTEMBER–OCTOBER 1994
The Air Transport System — Aircrew and Air Traffic Management Integration a joint meeting of FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION FRENCH NATIONAL ACADEMY OF AIR & SPACE Toulouse, France November 8–10, 1994
For more information contact J. Edward Peery, FSF.
(This meeting follows the joint meeting of FSF and the International Federation of
Airworthiness in Lisbon, Portugal, October 31–November 3, 1994.)
HUMAN FACTORS & AVIATION MEDICINE Copyright 1994 FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION INC. ISSN 1057-5545 Suggestions and opinions expressed in FSF publications belong to the author(s) and are not necessarily endorsed by Flight Safety Foundation. Content is not intended to take the place of information in company policy handbooks and equipment manuals, or to supersede government regulations.
Staff: Roger Rozelle, director of publications; Girard Steichen, assistant director of publications;
Kate Achelpohl, editorial assistant; Rick Darby, editorial consultant; and Dwyane D. Feaster, production consultant.
Subscriptions: US$60 (U.S.-Canada-Mexico), US$65 Air Mail (all other countries), six issues yearly. • Include oldand new addresses when requesting address change. • Flight Safety Foundation, 2200 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 500,Arlington, VA 22201-3306 U.S. • telephone: (703) 522-8300 • telex: 901176 FSF INC AGTN • fax: (703) 525-6047
We Encourage Reprints
Articles in this publication may be reprinted in whole or in part, but credit must be given to: Flight Safety Foundation, Human Factors &Aviation Medicine, the specific article and the author. Please send two copies of reprinted material to the director of publications. What’s Your Input?
In keeping with FSF’s independent and nonpartisan mission to disseminate objective safety information, Foundation publicationssolicit credible contributions that foster thought-provoking discussion of aviation safety issues. If you have an article proposal,a completed manuscript or a technical paper that may be appropriate for Human Factors & Aviation Medicine, please contact thedirector of publications. Reasonable care will be taken in handling a manuscript, but Flight Safety Foundation assumes noresponsibility for material submitted. The publications staff reserves the right to edit all published submissions. Payment ismade to author upon publication. Contact the Publications Department for more information.
FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION • HUMAN FACTORS & AVIATION MEDICINE • SEPTEMBER–OCTOBER 1994
Trouble n°1 Hiver 2002 Élisabeth Wetterwald Maurizio Cattelan, le prozac et la ciguë 2001 Cattelan et les sciences humaines On a déjà beaucoup comparé Maurizio Cattelan à un clown, à un bouffon ou encore à l’idiot du village ; image que l’artiste cherche aussi sans doute à donner de lui- même. S’il est en effet tentant de le considérer comme l’éternel farceur, toujou